California holds postnups to the strictest standard in the country. Under Family Code § 721, spouses occupy a confidential relationship and owe each other a duty of the highest good faith and fair dealing, and the transmutation rules of Family Code §§ 850 to 853 govern how marital and separate property are reclassified. Any agreement that advantages one spouse triggers a presumption of undue influence, and the advantaged spouse must rebut it. California courts test fairness both at signing and at enforcement, and In re Marriage of Burkle confirmed that hidden financial details will sink even a sophisticated postnup. Independent counsel for each spouse is the practical price of enforceability here.
Texas is comparatively permissive. Family Code § 4.105 makes a marital property agreement enforceable unless the challenging spouse proves it was signed involuntarily or was unconscionable when signed and that spouse was not given a fair disclosure, did not waive disclosure, and had no adequate knowledge of the other's finances. Texas courts respect partition-and-exchange agreements between spouses, which gives a postnup real teeth, though the disclosure and voluntariness requirements still bind.
New York enforces postnups under Domestic Relations Law § 236(B)(3), which requires the agreement to be in writing, signed by both parties, and acknowledged before a notary in the same form required to record a deed. That acknowledgment formality is unforgiving; New York courts have voided agreements signed without proper notarization regardless of fairness. New York also scrutinizes postnups for fraud, duress, and unconscionability given the spousal relationship.
Florida has no postnup statute and applies common-law contract principles refined by Casto v. Casto. The agreement must rest on full disclosure or the challenging spouse's independent knowledge of assets, and a court will set aside terms procured by fraud, duress, coercion, or overreaching. A Florida postnup that fairly discloses finances and is signed without pressure will generally stand. For couples filing toward divorce in any of these states, the postnup's terms often feed directly into the marital settlement and family law documents a court ultimately incorporates.