California treats a good-faith demand letter as protected prelitigation speech under the litigation privilege of Cal. Civ. Code §47(b), which is why recipients rarely succeed in suing over one. That protection has a hard edge. In Flatley v. Mauro the California Supreme Court held that a letter threatening criminal exposure to extract payment was extortion as a matter of law, stripped of the privilege and of the anti-SLAPP shelter at Code of Civil Procedure §425.16. Defamation senders should also note Civil Code §48a, which requires a correction demand within twenty days of a newspaper or broadcast publication and otherwise limits recovery to special damages.
New York amended its anti-SLAPP regime through Civil Rights Law §§70-a and 76-a to cover communications connected to any issue of public interest, with attorney fee recovery for a successful movant. A letter threatening meritless litigation over a critical review can end with the sender paying the recipient's counsel.
Texas imposes the strictest sequence of the four. Under the Defamation Mitigation Act at Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code §73.055, a claimant who fails to request a correction, clarification, or retraction within ninety days of learning of the publication loses exemplary damages, and the request must identify the statement with particularity and allege its defamatory meaning. The Texas Citizens Participation Act at §27.003 adds an aggressive dismissal mechanism with a sixty-day motion deadline. A Texas letter over speech should read as a statutory retraction request from the first line.
Florida requires five days written notice specifying the allegedly false statements before any civil action for libel or slander, under Fla. Stat. §770.01. Courts applying Florida law have extended that requirement to online publishers and bloggers, so an informal email that skipped the statutory format can bar the case outright. The anti-SLAPP statute at §768.295 adds fee exposure for suits filed to chill protected speech. Comparable traps exist in most states, and the state selector across our US business contract templates accounts for them.